I like to ridicule the New York Times‘ earnest, patronizing coverage of immigration. At root, it’s always meant to cause pity, which is not a very humanizing emotion. Immigrants, in the Times‘ world, are victims. It’s especially frustrating because immigration to a foreign land is not pitiful. It is courageous, dangerous, and bold, which should theoretically make for some incredible stories of people with the kind of can-do, entreprenurial attitudes that make America great.
In that respect, the Times could learn something from Letras Libres, a Mexican/Spanish magazine that this month has an amazing story about a typical Mexican immigrant named Benavides Huaroco. It’s a story that breaks all the narrative cliches of typical immigration coverage in the English media. There are no victims here, just characters you can empathize with and root for.
In a nutshell, Benavides Huaroco is a subsistence farmer in Cheran. He sees his friends coming back from America, all elegant, speaking English, wearing new Converse, and he decides - you know what? - he’s going to get himself a pair of new shoes.
He has adventures. He gets chased by the Mexican authorities, gets screwed by his first employer, and returns back home empty-handed. He swears to never return, but his friend talks him into it, and they go back to work on a farm in Alabama. There are kind gringo employers that give him a hand. One of those gringos comments for the article:
“People like this are what make this country work… You want to make a lot of money? Then find some way to bring more families like that here, but legally. Businesses here need that labor, and if you can find a way to bring them here without problems, you’re gonna make very good money. The only thing they want is to feed their families with dignity. They’re good people, and hard workers.”
There’s nothing candy coated about the story. One time Mr. Huaroco got his drivers license suspended after he got caught drunk driving. Another time he has a racially-charged run-in with his African-American manager. It’s tough for Mr. Huaroco. But you know what? You don’t pity him. You cheer him on. You want him to succeed.
And in the end, when he’s making a healthy living selling Mexican music and sundry paraphernalia in his shop outside Foley, Alabama, and when he’s brought almost his entire family to live and work in the States, and when he’s still living in a mobile home because he wistfully keeps one foot in his homeland, you don’t feel sorry for him, because you know that from being a poor subsistence farmer in the back country of Mexico who just wanted a new pair of Converse, Mr. Huaroco has done pretty damn good for himself.
Why can’t the English media manage to find stories like this? Is it too cheesy? Not ironic/existential/desperate enough, the way immigrants are supposed to be? We’re all post-American Dream, right? Jaded in our upper-middle class malaise. Well, there’s got to be some reason 11 million people have entered this country illegally in the last two decades.
And I don’t think it was to become victims.