Dubious. Very, very dubious.
Saturday, September 9, 2006
Noting that a new movie version of Robert Penn Warren’s All the King’s Men is preparing to launch, I feel compelled to warn everyone to please - please - read the book before you go watch the movie. It’s 650 pages long, and they’re the kind of 650 pages that you read in three days, turning them feverishly on buses, subways, in cars, while walking from place to place, over fast food lunches, and while smoking way too many cigarettes at three in the morning.
Then, after you read All the King’s Men, go find a good biography on Huey P. Long, the real-life Louisiana governor on which Warren’s book is based, and read that. It’s almost better than a novel. Long was the closest thing any of the 50 states ever had to a populist, totalitarian leader. One example: After he was elected to the US Senate, he still ran Louisiana through a puppet governor. If he hadn’t been assassinated, who knows where he might have ended up.
After doing both these things, you’ll probably harbor no desire to see this epic story chopped into a 2-hour film, especially one staring Shawn Penn sporting a shit-eating pencil mustache. Maybe he can play a corn-fed Louisiana good-ol-boy with a pug nose and a seer-sucker suit, but I wouldn’t put my money on it. As a parallel, try imagining Hugh Grant playing Indiana Jones.
Yeech.
If it were Johny Depp, I’d be curious to see how he was going to pull it off, but as it is, I think I’ll just save my $12 and buy another used copy of the book.
